Can Renovations Actually Increase My Home’s Value? Here’s the Truth

If you’re thinking about selling and staring down a list of home projects, you might be asking yourself:

“Should I fix it up before I sell?”
“Will I get that money back?”
“Do buyers really care about this stuff?”

Those are great questions — and they’re ones I’ve walked through hundreds of times with homeowners over the last two decades.

With over 20 years of experience in new construction, remodeling, and real estate, I’ve seen what actually helps homes sell — and what ends up being a waste of time and money.

So let’s walk through it together.

Start with the End in Mind

Before you pick up a hammer or call a contractor, the first question to ask is:

“What would buyers in my neighborhood actually pay for?”

Not what you love. Not what your cousin suggested.
But what real buyers are looking for — and what they’re willing to pay more for in your specific area of Gainesville or Hall County.

That’s where a competitive market analysis comes in. I’ll show you what’s selling right now, what those homes look like, and what’s actually moving the needle. If you haven’t seen your current market, take a look at your ZIP code:

• 30506

• 30501

• 30504

• 30507

• 30542

• 30527

• 30554

Renovations That Usually Add Value

If you're going to make improvements before listing, these are the ones I typically recommend — based on both buyer behavior and my own construction experience:

Paint

• Neutral colors like greige, soft whites, or light taupe

• Clean, updated feel without breaking the bank

Curb Appeal

• Mulch, trimmed shrubs, power-washed siding or driveway, and a fresh front door

• First impressions (especially online) matter — this can offer a 3x–5x ROI in buyer perception

Kitchen & Bath Refreshes

• Not full remodels — think updated hardware, new faucets, light fixtures, and painted cabinets

• Re-grouting tile or replacing outdated counters can go a long way

Flooring

• If the carpet’s worn or the vinyl is peeling, consider replacing it with affordable LVP

• Consistent flooring through the main areas shows better in both photos and showings

Lighting & Fixtures

• Matte black, brushed gold, or brushed nickel finishes can modernize a space instantly

Upgrades That Don’t Always Pay Off

This is where I see a lot of well-meaning sellers spend big — and not get much back:

Custom Additions
That sunroom, wine cellar, or built-in entertainment center might have personal value… but most buyers don’t assign the same dollar value to it.

Swimming Pools
Great in theory — expensive in reality. Pools can scare off buyers due to maintenance and liability.

High-End Finishes in Modest Homes
Over-improving for your price point rarely pays off. In a $300K neighborhood, a $60K custom kitchen may limit your buyer pool more than help.

DIY Work That Looks DIY
If it’s not done right, it can raise red flags. Even well-intended projects can backfire if they look unprofessional during inspections.

So… Should You Renovate Before You Sell?

Maybe. But maybe not.

And that’s where having someone like me on your side makes all the difference.

I’ll walk your home with a buyer’s eye and tell you:

• What’s worth fixing

• What to leave alone

• What today’s buyers actually care about

• And how to price your home based on its current condition

Sometimes, small updates lead to big wins.
Other times, it makes more sense to sell as-is and let buyers make it their own.

You don’t need to guess. I’ll help you weigh your options with clarity and no pressure. To dig deeper check out: What to Fix Before Selling Your Gainesville Home (And What to Skip)

Want Help Deciding?

I’ve created detailed blog guides just like this to walk Gainesville and Hall County homeowners through the process. If you're still weighing your options, you might also want to check out:

Why Overpricing Can Actually Cost You More in the End

Built on grit. Fueled by faith. Committed to home.
Want to know who's behind these blogs? Click here to learn more about me and my mission.

Not Sure What’s Worth Fixing?
Let’s walk it together. I’ll give you honest, no-pressure advice on where to spend — and where to skip — before you list.
Click here to request your free home value review